Mato Recordings example. Source recording: "Inside the FBI Podcast: Top Ten Fugitive Ruja Ignatova" by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (Public domain). Vaporware is a show produced on Mato; the source publisher is not affiliated with it. Made with Mato from this recording.

Inside the FBI · Top Ten Fugitive


Its private blockchain hid transactions from investors, while the company set OneCoin's value.

Read the story Made from a public domain FBI recording

One recording: the OneCoin case

All stories
  1. 1

    How OneCoin's private blockchain let the company set its own price

    Read it below

  2. 2

    Secrecy and charisma: the two scam warning signs the FBI draws from OneCoin

    Article

  3. 3

    The 'Bitcoin killer' that wasn't: two scam red flags from the OneCoin case

    The Postmortem

The story, written

How OneCoin's private blockchain let the company set its own price

Investigators say OneCoin borrowed the language of cryptocurrency while running a ledger only the company could see. Here is how that let the company, not the market, decide what the coin was worth.

Vaporware · Made from the Inside the FBI recording on Ruja Ignatova

Crypto words without crypto practices

OneCoin used the vocabulary of cryptocurrency: mining, blockchain, exchange, a coin price that climbed. According to investigators, it used the words without the practices. Prosecutors laid out that case in filings tied to co-founder Karl Sebastian Greenwood's guilty plea, saying the coins were never mined with computer resources, the ledger was not a true blockchain, and the price came from the company itself.

This article stays on the mechanics: how a private, centralized ledger differs from an open one, and why that difference let a company decide what its coin was worth. The founder's biography and the recruiting network are outside its scope.

The stakes were large. Victims invested over four billion dollars worldwide in the fraudulent coin, according to the Southern District of New York.

The mining story investigators dispute

Mining, in most cryptocurrencies, means computers doing the work that keeps the network running. Bitcoin, for example, is secured by a global network of miners who maintain a public ledger, according to CNBC's reporting on the OneCoin case.

OneCoin's leaders claimed their coin was mined on servers the company maintained and operated. Investigators believe it was not, and the plea filings say OneCoins were never mined using computer resources.

The emails quoted in those filings show how the story was built. In an August 11, 2014 message, Greenwood proposed getting members to think they were mining their OneCoin by exchanging tokens for coins. The next day he called mining a concept familiar in the industry and a story the company could sell to members. When Ignatova wrote that the company was not actually mining, Greenwood asked how that could be investigated and found out.

Greenwood pleaded guilty to wire fraud and money laundering charges in December 2022, and these emails come from the government's account of that case.

Public and decentralized versus private and centralized

A public, decentralized blockchain is an open ledger. Every user can see the transactions across the currency, and no single company controls the record. That visibility lets a network of strangers agree on who owns what.

OneCoin claimed something different. FBI Special Agent Ronald Shimko has said OneCoin claimed to have a private blockchain, in contrast to other virtual currencies, which have a decentralized and public one.

A private, centralized ledger sits on one party's systems and shows its contents to that party. Prosecutors describe OneCoin's claimed ledger as a digital ledger identifying OneCoins and recording historical transactions. Whoever holds such a ledger decides what it says, and everyone else reads the company's reports.

Detail of the Vaporware key art: pink smoke curling out of a glowing cyan wireframe computer.
Vaporware key art.

How supply and demand set value on an open network

On an open network, a coin's price is the record of many separate decisions. Buyers bid, sellers ask, and trades happen where the two meet. Because the trades are visible, anyone can see whether a price reflects activity or a thin, staged market. Demand that outruns supply pushes the price up, and a rush to sell pushes it down.

Prosecutors say OneCoin falsely claimed that its value rested on market supply and demand, when in fact the value was simply set by OneCoin itself.

Remove the visible ledger and the open trading, and the check disappears. Nobody outside the company can compare a quoted price with a real trade. NBC News reported that prosecutors say the coin had no blockchain behind it and that Ignatova made up the price. The coins, according to the same report, were not traded.

OneCoin as the only one watching the ledger

With a ledger only the company could read, nothing independent checked what the company said. Shimko described the result in plain terms: “In this case, investors were just asked to trust OneCoin.”

Public blockchains exist to reduce how much trust a holder must place in any single party. OneCoin's claimed design removed that protection while keeping the vocabulary.

In this case, investors were just asked to trust OneCoin.

FBI Special Agent Ronald Shimko

What court filings say about setting the price

Prosecutors' account of the Greenwood plea quotes emails that treat price control as a design goal. On June 9, 2014, Ignatova wrote to a representative of a blockchain development company that OneCoin wanted an internal exchange where it could set the price manually and automatically and also control the traded volume.

The emails continued into 2015. On March 21, 2015, Ignatova wrote to Greenwood, “We can manipulate the exchange by simulating some volatility and intraday pricing.” In an August 1, 2015 email, her list of goals included closing each day on a high price and opening the next day high, to build confidence.

The resulting chart ran in one direction. The purported value of a OneCoin grew steadily from €0.50 to approximately €29.95 per coin, and it never decreased. A coin traded openly would be expected to rise and fall.

Ignatova remains at large, so her emails remain allegations in the government's account.

Was there a real blockchain at all?

Two statements need separating. OneCoin claimed a private blockchain. According to the plea filing, OneCoin lacked a true blockchain, that is, a public and verifiable blockchain.

The filing adds that by approximately March 2015, Ignatova and Greenwood had started allocating to members coins that did not even exist in the purported private blockchain, and they referred to those coins as “fake coins.”

OCCRP quoted prosecutors saying the deceit included simulating transactions through a fake blockchain meant to function as a digital ledger. CNBC reported investigators' view that the project had no blockchain securing transactions and that coins were essentially minted out of thin air.

Whether the ledger was private or absent, a holder's position was the same: no way to confirm a balance or follow a transaction.

Why investors could not trace their holdings

In 2019, then-FBI Assistant Director-in-Charge William Sweeney Jr. said that OneCoin offered investors no method of tracing their money and could not be used to purchase anything.

Victims wired funds to OneCoin-controlled bank accounts to buy OneCoin packages. The coins they received could not be checked against any outside record.

Growth came through a multi-level marketing network in which members earned commissions for recruiting others, a structure the filing says drove rapid expansion. OCCRP reported that at least 3.5 million people around the world bought in.

OneCoin's own records show €4.037 billion in sales revenue between the fourth quarter of 2014 and the fourth quarter of 2016, according to the filing. In the U.S. attorney's words, “OneCoins were entirely worthless.”

Warning signs readers can use

The FBI's advice in the episode behind this article is short. An investment that is secretive in nature is probably a scam, and investing on someone's personal talent or charisma instead of underlying facts is another warning sign. Applied to a coin, that advice becomes a few direct questions.

  • Can you see the coin's transactions on a public ledger that the seller does not control?
  • Is the price set by trades you can watch on more than one independent venue?
  • Can you move or spend the coin without asking the company that sold it?
  • Does the pitch lean on a person's résumé and stage presence more than on documents you can check?

OneCoin's pitch leaned on the stage. At Wembley Arena in 2016, Ignatova repeatedly compared her coin to Bitcoin, saying OneCoin was “supposed to be the Bitcoin killer.” Investors were asked to trust a company about its own ledger and its own price, and any pitch that asks the same deserves the same scrutiny.

Key takeaways

  1. 1Investigators say OneCoins were never mined with computer resources, despite the company's mining claims.
  2. 2OneCoin claimed a private, centralized blockchain that only the company could see, while public blockchains show transactions to every user.
  3. 3Court filings describe emails about setting the price manually and simulating volatility, and the purported price never fell.
  4. 4Secrecy and reliance on charisma are warning signs, because an investor cannot verify either.

Further reading

The story in three clips

Three short cuts from the recording, for the people who will not sit through the whole thing. Send them one.

The Postmortem

The letter that goes with each episode, made from the same recording. This issue: the OneCoin case and the two red flags the FBI points to.

Free. No pitches. Unsubscribe in one click.

Vaporware · The Postmortem

Latest issue

The 'Bitcoin killer' that wasn't: two scam red flags from the OneCoin case

Its private blockchain hid transactions from investors, while the company set OneCoin's value.

OneCoin claimed more than two million active users. But investors had no way to track their coins or transactions, and their holdings ended up worthless. The combined losses exceeded $4 billion.

OneCoin called its blockchain private and centralized, so only the company could see transactions. The company, not market demand, set the coin’s value. The FBI’s two warnings are direct: be wary of secretive investments, and judge an investment by its facts, not someone’s charisma. Ruja Ignatova remains a fugitive; tips can be reported anonymously at tips.fbi.gov.

Read the full issue in the archive

Where the conversation went

@vaporwarepod everywhere

Vaporware

@vaporwarepod

Ruja Ignatova, the Cryptoqueen, was charged over the OneCoin fraud in 2017. The episode says she flew from Sofia to Athens on October 25 and "has not been seen since." She's on the FBI's Ten Most Wanted list. Tips: tips.fbi.gov, anonymous is fine.

ReplyRepostLikeShare

Vaporware Podcast

Podcast

The FBI's warning from the OneCoin case is simple.

The speaker says investors had no real way to track their OneCoin or the transactions across the currency. In the end, their investments were worthless, and together they lost "the equivalent of more than four billion U.S. dollars."

The advice that follows: "Any investment that is secretive in nature is probably a scam."

The speaker adds a second warning sign. Investing based on someone's "personal talent or charisma rather than underlying facts" is also a signal you may be falling victim to a scam.

If you can't see how the money moves, and the main reason to trust it is the person selling it, that is worth pausing on.

#investorprotection #fraudawareness #OneCoin

LikeCommentRepostSend

vaporwarepod

Stylized wanted poster with a blank silhouette beside a world map with several countries highlighted.

vaporwarepod Only the eleventh woman ever added to the FBI's Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list.

That's how the speaker describes Ruja Ignatova, noting the list "was created in nineteen fifty." She has not been seen since 2017.

What the episode lays out:
Age: 42
Eyes: brown
Hair: dark brown to black, though investigators believe she could have changed her physical appearance
Languages: English, German and Bulgarian
May be traveling on a fraudulent passport
Known connections: Bulgaria, Germany, Russia, Greece and the United Arab Emirates

The speaker adds she's "known to have lived a lavish lifestyle."

If you have information, contact your local FBI office or the nearest American embassy or consulate. You can also report tips online at tips.fbi.gov. In the speaker's words, "Tipsters can remain anonymous."

#InsideTheFBI #TenMostWanted #FBI